Statement issued by the Hon. Dr. Kenneth Baugh on the Shanique Myrie case


On March 23, 2011, Ms. Shanique Myrie lodged a formal complaint with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade, in which she reported abusive and degrading treatment meted out to her at the hands of Border Services Officers at the Grantley Adams International Airport, on 14 March, 2011. My statement to Parliament on 29 March, 2011, conveyed the outrage which all Jamaicans felt about the alleged abuse and the firm intention of the Government of Jamaica that a comprehensive investigation be undertaken.

To this end, a Jamaican Delegation comprised of High Commissioner Sharon Saunders (based in Port of Spain); the CEO of the Passport, Citizenship and Immigration Agency; Crown Counsel in the Attorney General’s Chambers (with expertise in human rights law) and the Deputy Superintendent of Police in the Organized Crimes Unit of the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF), was dispatched to Barbados on 30 March to carry out preliminary investigations.  On arrival, High Commissioner Saunders, who headed Jamaica’s delegation, met with a Barbadian delegation, led by Senator the Honourable Maxine McClean, Minister of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade, including a Minister of State and a Parliamentary Secretary, both from the Office of the Prime Minister.

At that meeting, the Barbadian delegation re-affirmed the information contained in the Press Release issued by the Barbados Government Information Service (BGIS) on March 26, that Miss Myrie’s allegations were unfounded.  The High Commissioner was advised that the Barbadian Prime Minister had met all officers who were involved in the case and he was satisfied that the matter was addressed thoroughly and conclusively.

High Commissioner Saunders referred to a statement made to the Barbadian media by the Parliamentary Secretary in the Office of the Prime Minister, with responsibility for Immigration, linking Ms. Myrie to human trafficking occurring between Jamaica and Barbados. He had claimed that the Authorities were aware of this trafficking.    The Barbadian Foreign Minister did not agree that the statement was meant to imply human trafficking in the internationally-accepted definition of the term.  Notwithstanding, this erroneous statement to the media must be withdrawn.

The Barbadian delegation stressed that there was no discrimination or prejudice against Jamaicans, but the laws of the land would always be observed.  They emphasised that anecdotal reports do not constitute evidence of abuse, discrimination or prejudice.

However, subsequent meetings between the full Jamaican delegation and high officials of the Barbadian delegation, a tour of the detention facilities at the Grantley Adams International Airport and a well-attended meeting with the Jamaican community in Barbados, led the delegation to the unanimous conclusion that there are widespread perceptions of negative attitudes towards Jamaicans and that Miss Myrie’s report was deserving of the fullest investigation.

The delegation made a full report to the Honourable Prime Minister Bruce Golding and myself on 4 April, 2011.  We accept its conclusion.  Furthermore, the Government of Jamaica considers the Press Release of the BGIS, issued on 26 March, to be an unacceptable response to the formal communication from Jamaica.  The Government of Jamaica will be vigorously pursuing this matter.  Indeed, details of the delegation’s report were shared with Miss Myrie’s Attorneys-at-Law, to assist them in determining how best to proceed on her behalf, as the alleged degrading cavity search was illegal.

Clearly, due process can only be served when Miss Myrie is afforded the opportunity to identify the persons who interrogated her. 

The Minister of Foreign Affairs of Barbados has already indicated that she would welcome a visit from Miss Myrie to Barbados, for the purpose of pursuing further investigations.

Consultations are ongoing on the course of action which should be pursued.  Above all, it must be clearly understood that the Government of Jamaica takes very seriously its responsibility to protect and defend the rights of its citizens. Miss Myrie’s case will be pursued on its own merit and so will other cases which have been reported to my Ministry.

Bilaterally and regionally, Jamaica and CARICOM partners must frankly confront any unacceptable intra-regional attitude and action which undermine the very fabric of Community. It is not an overstatement to say that the entire CARICOM project could be injured by a refusal to deal with these matters with the frankness and honesty worthy of a Community where mutual trust and respect are essential to the achievement of the objectives of the region.

 

Issued by: The Ministry of Foreign Affairs & Foreign Trade

JIS Social